Palm Trees Spark Controversy at Cotswold Cottage in England's 'Prettiest Street'

Two tall palm trees adorned with fairy lights in the garden of Rosemary Cottage on Awkward Hill, Bibury—part of the celebrated Arlington Row, often called “England’s prettiest street”—have become the focus of a local planning dispute. The trees, Trachycarpus fortunei or windmill palms, have been described by residents as “so out of place” amid the traditional Cotswold stone cottages and lush historic surroundings.

The property has been under renovation since 2023, sparking complaints from villagers about prolonged construction disrupting the tranquil village atmosphere. Proposed works include replacing the Cotswold stone slate roof tiles, adding insulation, and plans for an oak conservatory and stone summerhouse. Previous proposals even considered an underground garage, heightening local concerns over preserving the area’s heritage.

Victoria Summerley, a Bibury resident and garden author living next door, responded to comments by the applicant’s architect, Matthew Hollingsworth of Spirit Architecture Ltd, who argued that the palm trees have existed on the site for over 20 years and form part of the property’s history. Ms. Summerley, however, pointed out that nearly all other garden plants have been removed, leaving the palms starkly prominent and increasingly conspicuous due to fairy light decorations.

She explained that the palms were originally planted by a former neighbor and are well-suited as hardy UK specimens. While she values diverse plantings and opposes restricting what can be grown, she questioned the claim that these trees are integral to Rosemary Cottage’s history. The garden once featured a lush variety of plants and a pond, blending softly into the landscape. Now, with only these palms remaining, they stand out, drawing tourists' remarks and even questions about whether the owner hails from Dubai.

Local conservation guidelines stress that alterations to listed buildings or properties in conservation areas should preserve or enhance the character of the place. Ms. Summerley believes the palm trees do not meet this standard for a traditional Cotswold cottage, stating, “I don’t think anyone with any sense could argue that two tall palm trees enhance or preserve the character of a three-bed cottage in the Cotswolds.”

Requests for further comment from Mr. Hollingsworth and the property owner were declined.

Palm Trees Spark Controversy at Cotswold Cottage in England’s ‘Prettiest Street’