Gloucestershire’s suspended chief constable, Rod Hansen, has become embroiled in a planning dispute in the Welsh village of Shirenewton, Monmouthshire. Hansen aims to convert a barn near Chepstow into a three-bedroom home, but residents and local councillors have raised serious objections, citing environmental damage and procedural concerns.
The Shirenewton Community Council criticized the site’s recent clearance, noting the removal of the barn roof and undergrowth, which displaced protected species such as bats, great crested newts, and dormice during their breeding season. Objections highlight that an abundance of these species had been recorded near the site before construction began.
Controversy surrounds the timing and scope of ecological surveys. Critics point out that the preliminary bat survey was conducted in December during the daytime—an inopportune period for capturing accurate wildlife activity—arguing this undermines the validity of the ecological assessments. They called for a comprehensive appraisal and remediation measures to offset the significant environmental impact already caused.
READ MORE: Tewkesbury’s Equinox Maintenance Limited Enters Administration After 42 Years of Service
Opponents also note a delay between the start of construction in July and the submission of amended planning applications in September, suggesting a disregard for planning protocols. Concerns have been raised that the enforcement of planning and wildlife protection laws might be inconsistent.
In response, Hansen’s planning agent, architect Richard Liddell, contends that a 2005 planning permission remains valid and justifies ongoing building work without the need for retrospective approval. He emphasizes evidence showing the development was lawfully initiated, with materials on-site and concrete poured for the original extension, and compliant with building regulations overseen by inspectors.
Liddell notes that a full ecological review has been undertaken, revealing minimal bat activity and only limited signs of dormice far from the barn. Efforts to enhance biodiversity on the property include planting approximately 400 mixed native saplings and restoring a historic pond to support wildlife habitats. A management plan aims to maintain ecological diversity through controlled clearing and encouraging natural regrowth.
Monmouthshire County Council is yet to make a decision regarding the application to amend the barn’s planning conditions, as community debates and environmental scrutiny continue.