When making a cheese toastie, many reach for butter to spread on the bread’s exterior for that classic crispiness. However, chef James Lamprey, renowned for his creative recipes on TikTok, swears by a better method.
In a popular video, James shares his foolproof way to craft the best grilled cheese sandwich. His key tip? Spread mayonnaise on the bread instead of butter. According to James, mayonnaise cooks evenly and prevents the bread from burning, delivering a perfectly golden crust every time.
He instructs: “Spread mayonnaise on your bread and place it mayo-side down in the pan. Then add your cheese and top with the other slice of bread.”
READ MORE: Man Seriously Injured After Car Falls on Him While Working
READ MORE: Tripadvisor Ranks Painswick Rococo Gardens Among Top 10% of Attractions Worldwide
James also introduces a clever flipping technique that avoids the usual mess. Instead of flipping the sandwich directly with a spatula, he recommends flipping the entire frying pan upside down over the uncooked side of the sandwich, then gently sliding it back into the pan. This technique keeps the toastie intact and produces a flawless crust.
The method has sparked plenty of reactions online. Some viewers praised James, with comments like, “I’ve been doing this for years – it’s the best way to make grilled cheese,” and “The mayo tip was a game changer!” However, others questioned the pan-flip method, suggesting alternatives such as using two spatulas or covering the pan with a lid to melt the cheese before flipping normally.
Ultimately, James Lamprey’s tips encourage home cooks to rethink their grilled cheese approach — mayo for a crispy, burn-free finish and a smart flip to keep it tidy and delicious.