Residents of Bibury, dubbed “England’s prettiest village,” are expressing confusion and concern following a council decision regarding proposed plans for a new cafe at the village’s popular Trout Farm. The fear is that the development will exacerbate already frequent traffic gridlock and safety risks in the tourist-heavy Cotswolds hotspot.
Bibury, renowned for its Arlington Row weaver’s cottages and immortalized by 19th-century textile designer William Morris as “the most beautiful village in England,” has faced mounting challenges due to overtourism. The narrow rural lanes, frequented by large numbers of tourists, cars, and coaches, regularly experience congestion and unsafe pedestrian conditions.
The Cotswold District Council recently reviewed plans to convert part of the barns at Bibury Trout Farm into a cafe and shopping area. The scheme includes modifications to existing structures such as the Shoecroft Barn on Ablington Lane. Project consultants emphasized the sensitive design intended to respect the historic setting while revitalizing the buildings.
READ MORE: Police Seek Man with Bike Following Severe Attack in Gloucester City Centre
READ MORE: Major Maintenance on A40 Over Bridge to Cause Significant Delays
However, the proposal has sparked significant opposition, with over 100 objections citing worsening traffic pressure. Bibury Parish Council submitted details highlighting “dangerous” traffic congestion observed during the early May bank holiday of 2025, describing pedestrian movement along the lane as “staggering and blatantly unsafe,” particularly because there is no direct pedestrian access from the Trout Farm car parks to the village proper.
Parish council chairman Craig Chapman strongly voiced these concerns, emphasizing that Ablington Lane is a narrow, rural route used by residents and emergency vehicles not built to handle commercial traffic increases. He noted existing issues, including gridlock, verge erosion, and conflicts between vehicles and pedestrians, and explained a community group, Bibury One, has been formed to seek solutions for parking and highway safety problems stemming from overtourism.
Chapman warned the new cafe could become an independent destination, drawing even more visitors and traffic. He underscored that the highways authority has recommended refusing the application on safety grounds, urging decision-makers to heed their concerns and not undermine the ongoing community efforts to manage visitor impact.
Local resident Michelle Holt echoed the sentiment that expanding the Trout Farm’s commercial operations would impose an unfair burden on the small village, arguing there is no demonstrated need for another cafe and that further visitor influx could harm residents’ quality of life, safety, and the environment.
Councillor David Fowles, representing Bibury on the district council, concurred with the highway objections and pointed to the village’s existing several cafes, including the recently opened Number 11. He described daily traffic chaos involving mixed vehicles and pedestrians, calling the situation “an accident waiting to happen.”
During the council meeting, multiple members expressed concerns about road safety, recounting personal experiences narrowly avoiding accidents during site visits. Despite officers noting there is no formal traffic impact assessment accompanying the application, councillors voted not to reject the scheme outright but to defer the decision pending further evidence.
Cllr Paul Evans requested data quantifying potential traffic increases from the cafe, while others argued that visible safety risks and prior objections should suffice to warrant refusal. Ultimately, the proposal to approve failed narrowly, and a unanimous vote deferred the matter for more detailed highway and air quality assessments.
Afterwards, Cllr Chapman expressed village residents’ confusion over the outcome, stating: “There seemed to be general agreement about the issue of safety. So how on earth is another look at this application going to resolve that? If the application is granted, it can only make things worse. It was a very strange turnaround. The village is bemused.”
The council will revisit the planning application at a future meeting as residents and officials continue to grapple with balancing tourism benefits against preserving safety and village character.